Lo Hobbit diventerà un film...

[Marphil]

Lo hobbit è senza dubbio il libro di Tolkien che scorre + facile. Nato come una favola per bambini, è estremamente lineare come racconto.

A me personalmente è piaciuto molto, indispensabile leggerlo prima di leggere Lotr

[Boroming]

chi dice che lotr è pesante perche nn passa più è solo per una questione di principio.

voglio dire è proprio grazie a quelle descrizioni dettagliate che riesci a immergerti completamente in ciò che dice, nel luogo, nel personaggio; è questa la bellazza dei libri di tolkien. cosi come il silmarillion.

al contrario dei libri nn descrittivi che si si leggono meglio, ma ti dicono il 10% di quello che ti dice lotr

[Shub]

silmarillion>>>>>lo hobbit e lotr

[Faramjr]

silmarillion>>>>>lo hobbit e lotr

E qui te l'appoggio...

[Drako]

E qui te l'appoggio...

Se lo a la futura moglie

[Shub]

Seee...vi garberebbe

[Brely]

solo ke fare un film sul silmarillion è praticamente impossibile

[Wayne]

chi dice che lotr è pesante perche nn passa più è solo per una questione di principio.

Chi dice che lotr e' pesante e non passa piu' ha solo dei gusti diversi dai tuoi.

E de gustibus...

[Kith]

ma soprattutto bilbo da vecchio deve rimanere lo stesso attore sennò cazzincul...

[Boroming]

Chi dice che lotr e' pesante e non passa piu' ha solo dei gusti diversi dai tuoi.
E de gustibus...

no il piacere o nn piacere del libro deriva al 90% dalla trama, la descritività (quindi "pesantenza") influisce minimamente... è solo una questione psicologica.

Perche se la trama piace e ce voglia di leggere quel libro la descritività aiuto a immaginare molto piu facilmente ed "entrare" nel libro

[Faramjr]

Da aicn.com

QUINT: I saw in Variety that THE HOBBIT came up. The MGM thing. Did you see this?


PETER JACKSON: Where the guy who runs MGM was announcing their tentpoles and saying they were doing TERMINATOR 4 and they want me to make 2 HOBBIT films? I was reading that this morning on the net. It's a rather strange thing to wake to. I'm up for it, but somebody should phone me because I'm getting a bit booked out at the moment!


Everybody asks me about THE HOBBIT, you know? But the reality is I've never had a conversation with anybody about it. Not one person has ever made a phone call to me. I don't know. The irony is that we're acquiring our own projects now and we're buying the rights to books. The reality is, to be quite honest with you, we're getting ourselves now nice and busy, in a good way, for the next 4 years. So, people have not (spoken to us) about THE HOBBIT and it's making it more and more impossible for us to be involved.


QUINT: So, if you got a phone call tomorrow telling you that you could have any budget you need and creative freedom, but it has to be finished and in theaters by December 2009. Would you find room for THE HOBBIT?


PETER JACKSON: Well, it depends. No one has phoned me, which is kind of weird, but I don't know. We're very, very excited and committed about the films that we're working on now, so I don't know. I'd have to sit down and look at it all. Obviously, I'm interested in THE HOBBIT, but right now we have no emotional investment in it. For the last few years, we have put our hearts into other projects. It would seem strange to have somebody else do it, although some part of me would be interested in going to see somebody else's HOBBIT, be able to buy my popcorn and go and sit and watch the film.


I'm not against that and if our schedule is impossible, then that's what they'll do. They'll certainly go and get someone else to make it. They won't wait, which is their right.


QUINT: Could your lawsuit against New Line be a problem?


PETER JACKSON: No. It's a seperate thing. I mean, I can't discuss the law suit, but it is just about rather dull audit issues, not people or projects. New Line called us about a Lord of the Rings box set a few weeks ago. A high definition one, so we are still talking.


QUINT: Maybe they will offer a settlement that includes The Hobbit.


PETER JACKSON: No. Well, they might, but we would never do that. Never. You make movies because you love the idea. You feel kind of emotionally driven. I would never commit to a 2 or 3 year project because of a court order! I mean, what a jinx. It would bring bad karma. No, our dull audit stuff can get figured out by lawyers or courts or whatever. We'll keep our movies completely untarnished by that.


QUINT: I think no matter what you should write some dialogue for Christopher Lee and pack up the robe, staff and beard and go film about 10 minutes with him playing Saruman again while you still have the chance!


PETER JACKSON: I would love to! If I was doing THE HOBBIT I'd try to get as many of the guys back as I could. I mean, there's actually a role for Legolas in THE HOBBIT, his father features in it, obviously Gandalf and Saruman should be part of it. There's things that you can do with THE HOBBIT to bring in some old friends, for sure. I have thought about it from time to time... Elrond, Galadriel and Arwen could all feature. Elves have lived for centuries. Part of the attraction would be working with old friends. I wouldn't want to do it unless we could keep a continuity of cast. I have zero interest in directing a Gandalf who wasn't Ian McKellen for instance. Strange to be even talking about it, for three years it's been in this rights situation limbo.


QUINT: They must have figured it out.


PETER JACKSON: It looks that way. I've always thought that New Line would go to MGM and offer them some money and basically buy them out, then New Line would make the film. But I can see what MGM is doing. If I was MGM I'd do the same thing. What MGM is gotta be saying is, "Well, we'll partner in the film with you. We'll pay for half of it and you pay for half of it and we'll share it." That's what studios do a lot with these films. If I was MGM, I'd think that was the smart thing to do. "We'll share the rights," and actually become a partner in what is already a successful franchise.


It must create problems for New Line because they have all these output deals with these independent guys, who did a great job releasing LORD OF THE RINGS in all the different (foreign) territories. They release a package of New Line films over 2 or 3 years and they get 20 films or whatever. And I'm sure that New Line would prefer to offer their partners 20 films plus THE HOBBIT as part of the package, so MGM might be taking domestic and New Line international. I really have no idea, but it's interesting to see how the politics works. That stuff intrigues me. They must have figured out something I guess. I mean, there's too much money involved. If I was the Time/Warner board, I would have been hassling New Line for a Hobbit film for the last three years! It's a billion dollar franchise for the studio.


QUINT: And I'm sure they'd love the idea of two HOBBIT films. Twice the box office, more DVDs to sell...


PETER JACKSON: I saw that. Yeah, we're supposed to be writing The Lovely Bones, but of course Phil, Fran and I read the thing on the net and spent most of this morning talking about The Hobbit. We think the two film idea is really smart. One of the problems with The Hobbit is that it is a fairly simple kids story, and doesn't really feel like The Lord of the Rings. Tonally I mean. It's always may be a little worried, but with two films that kinda gets easier. It allows for more complexity. At that implied stuff with Gandalf and the White Council and the return of Sauron could be fully explored.

That's what we talked about this morning. Taking The Hobbit and combining it with all that intigue about Sauron's rise, and the problems that has for Gandalf. It could be cool. That way, it starts feeling more like The Lord of the Rings and less like this kids book. You could even get into Gollum's sneaking into Mordor and Aragorn protecting The Shire. That's what we'd do. Love to work with Viggo again.


Anyway, we talked for a while and got back into the Lovely Bones. As I said, that's where our hearts are at the moment. We're extremely happy with the projects we're involved in now and we're busy for a few years. I really have no idea. If someone else makes it, I'll be first in line! Actually, I'd try to be, but Philippa is the Queen of the Geeks and she'd definately get there first!

Non c'è bisogno di altri commenti, come al solito la stampa nostrana dimostra un'incompetenza impressionante.